Vermont Legalization (2018): The First State to Legalize by Legislature
Vermont's legislature passed the first U.S. cannabis legalization without voter ballot initiative in 2018.
Vermont legalized possession and home growing in 2018—a real watershed—but didn't create a legal sales market until 2022. That's often flattened into 'Vermont legalized in 2018' in the same way Colorado did. The genuine distinction is procedural: every prior U.S. legalization came through voter ballot; Vermont's came from lawmakers voting directly. That precedent mattered for later legislative states.
Background: Vermont's path to legalization
Vermont decriminalized small-amount cannabis possession in 2013 under Act 76, replacing criminal penalties with civil fines for up to one ounce [1]. The state had legalized medical cannabis in 2004 and expanded the program in 2011 to authorize dispensaries [2].
By the mid-2010s, neighboring states moved faster toward adult-use legalization. Massachusetts and Maine voters approved recreational cannabis in November 2016 via ballot referendum. Vermont, however, has no citizen ballot initiative process for statutory law—any legalization had to pass through the state legislature. That procedural constraint is what made Vermont's eventual legislative legalization historically distinctive Strong evidence.
2016: S.241 and the commercial market bid
The first serious legislative push came in 2016 with S.241, a bill that would have created a taxed and regulated commercial market. It passed the Vermont Senate but died in the House. Then-Governor Peter Shumlin (D) supported legalization and publicly advocated for it; House Speaker Shap Smith was more cautious, and the bill did not advance to a floor vote in the House Strong evidence.
This detail is often overlooked: Vermont's legislature attempted to legalize a commercial market first, failed, and only later succeeded with a narrower non-commercial model. The failure shaped the political pathway forward.
2017: H.170 and Governor Scott's conditional veto
In 2017, the legislature passed H.170, which would have legalized possession and home cultivation without permitting sales. Governor Phil Scott, a Republican, vetoed the bill in May 2017. However, Scott did not reject legalization on principle. His veto message instead focused on specific technical concerns: penalties for use around minors, impaired-driving provisions, and the structure of a study commission Strong evidence.
Scott explicitly invited the legislature to address his stated concerns and resubmit a revised bill. This conditional stance—a Republican governor signaling openness to legalization with modifications rather than outright opposition—was politically unusual nationally at that time in 2017.
H.511, Act 86, and January 2018 signing
In January 2018, the legislature returned with H.511, which incorporated Scott's suggested changes. Both chambers passed it. On January 22, 2018, Governor Scott signed the bill into law as Act 86, issuing a written statement that expressed lingering reservations even as he affixed his signature [3].
Act 86 took effect on July 1, 2018. Its core provisions [4]:
- Adults age 21 and older could possess up to 1 ounce of cannabis and 5 grams of hashish.
- Households could cultivate 2 mature and 4 immature plants for personal use.
- No legal commercial sales, no excise tax, no retail licensing.
This moment—January 22, 2018—is routinely cited as the first legislative legalization of adult-use cannabis in the United States Strong evidence. Every prior legalization (Colorado 2012, Washington 2012, Oregon 2014, Alaska 2014, California 2016, Maine 2016, Massachusetts 2016) had passed through citizen ballot initiative or referendum, not legislative vote.
The 'grow and give' regime and the myth of 2018 legalization
Act 86 created what advocates termed a 'grow and give' regime: legal to possess, legal to cultivate at home, and legal to gift cannabis, but illegal to sell it. There was no licensed retail market, no excise tax revenue, no social equity framework, and no requirement for testing or labeling of products outside the existing medical cannabis program.
Commercial cannabis sales were authorized separately by Act 164 (S.54), passed in October 2020 and signed (tacitly, without signature, allowed to become law) by Governor Scott [5]. Act 164 created the Vermont Cannabis Control Board and a licensing and regulatory framework. However, retail sales did not actually begin in Vermont until October 1, 2022—more than four years after Act 86 took effect.
A common myth: casual coverage conflates these two acts and describes Vermont as having 'legalized weed in 2018' in the same sense Colorado did in 2012. That misses a crucial distinction. Strong evidence Act 86 legalized possession and home cultivation but prohibited sales. Act 164 authorized the commercial market. They were separate acts, passed four years apart, with retail operations beginning two years after Act 164.
Key figures in the legislative push
- Phil Scott (R), Governor—Vetoed H.170 in 2017 with specific conditions; signed Act 86 in January 2018 despite reservations; later allowed Act 164 to become law without signature in 2020.
- Tim Ashe (D/P), Senate President Pro Tempore—Guided both H.170 and H.511 through the Vermont Senate.
- Mitzi Johnson (D), House Speaker—Managed House passage after the 2017 veto override effort and 2018 reintroduction.
- Maxine Grad (D), House Judiciary Committee Chair—Central to drafting both H.170 and H.511.
- Matt Simon, Marijuana Policy Project's New England political director—Long-standing legalization advocate who testified before the legislature throughout the 2014–2018 push, [3].
Why Vermont mattered—and why the myth grew
The practical scope of Act 86 was modest: a small state legalized personal possession and home cultivation. The procedural significance was real and unprecedented: every prior adult-use legalization in the U.S. had gone through a citizen ballot initiative, allowing legislators in those states to credit voters with the decision. Vermont's lawmakers could not. They had to vote directly and accept political ownership Strong evidence.
Later states that pursued legislative legalization cited Vermont's path as precedent—most notably Illinois (2021), Virginia (Virginia Cannabis Legalization (2021)), and New Jersey. The procedural precedent Vermont set was durable. The substantive myth that grew around it—that Vermont achieved 'full legalization' on par with Colorado in 2012—was not. That claim required the 2022 retail market opening to become accurate.
Sources
- Government Vermont General Assembly. Act 76 (2013), An act relating to the use and possession of marijuana.
- Government Vermont Department of Public Safety. Vermont Medical Marijuana Registry—Program History.
- Reported Gabriel, Trip (2018). 'Vermont Governor Signs Bill Legalizing Recreational Marijuana.' The New York Times, January 22, 2018.
- Government Vermont General Assembly (2018). Act 86 (H.511), An act relating to eliminating penalties for possession of limited amounts of marijuana by adults 21 years of age or older.
- Government Vermont General Assembly (2020). Act 164 (S.54), An act relating to the establishment of a regulated cannabis market.
How this page was made
Generation history
Drafted with AI assistance and checked by a separate automated fact-check pass. Not every article has been read by a person. See how articles are made.
Related
- Cannabis Laws in Vermont — Vermont legalized adult cannabis in 2018 and opened a regulated retail market in 2022.
- Federal Cannabis Law in the United States — How federal prohibition coexists with state legalization, and what may change.
- The First Billion-Dollar Cannabis Company — Canopy Growth crossed CA$1 billion in market cap in November 2016, driven by legalization...
- Virginia Cannabis Legalization (2021) — Virginia decriminalized cannabis in 2020 and legalized adult possession in 2021, becoming...
- William O'Shaughnessy and Cannabis — The Irish physician who published the first systematic study of cannabis in English medica...